Scenario Score Sheet
Each person who is grading our subjective scenarios is trained to a standard. When the person is grading they use a grade sheet specific to the question. The following grade sheet is used for the Skeletal Muscle Myopathy scenario.
SCORE SHEET
Scenario: Skeletal Muscle Myopathy
Name ________________________
General Problem Solving - 55 possible points from sections A, B and C
A. Form Hypothesis; 20 pts possible; select the statement that best applies
Score A: _____
- a. Stated and Correct (20)
- b. Implied and Correct (10)
- c. Implied Only (5)
- d. Stated and Incorrrect (10)
B. Design Experiments; 20 pts possible; select all that are mentioned or implied in the answer
Score B: _____
- a. Perform Test (5)
- b. Expt. Design, Controls, Comparison, Scientific Method (5)
- c. 1st Specific Test (5)
- d. 2nd Specific Test (3)
- e. Inappropriate Test (2)
C. Conclusions based on evidence/theory; 15 pts possible; select all that are mentioned or implied in the answer
Score C: _____
- a. Results used to compare organelles (5)
- b. Correct organelle has reduced activity (10)
Speciifc information - 30 possible points from sections D and E
D. Mitochondria; 15 pts possible; select all that are mentioned or implied in the answer
Score D: _____
- a. Mention (5)
- b. Specific assay - ATP synthesis, Succinate Dehydrogenase (5)
- c. Energy/ATP (5)
E. Golgi Apparatus; 15 pts possible; select all that are mentioned or implied in the answer
Score E: _____
- a. Mention (5)
- b. Specific assay such as glycosyl transferase (5)
- c.Protein processing (5)
Expert knowledge - 15 possible points from section F
F. Professional details; up to 15 pts possible; points received only if a topic is mentioned in general detail
Score F: _____
- a. Fractionation (5)
- b. Contamination (5)
- c. Personal history (5)
- d. Heredity (5)
- e. Instruments (5)
TOTAL _____/100
For more information you can contact Phil McClean, one of the co-project managers.
Copyright © 1998, 2000. World Wide Web Instructional Committee